The government keeps talking about bringing young people back to the countryside, as if nostalgia is a policy. I taught in Osaka for thirty-six years and watched the best students leave because there were no jobs, no hospitals, no future — and their parents, sensible people, did not stop them. Now we have empty schools and empty villages and politicians surprised that money alone does not make a young couple want to raise children in a place with one train per day. I walk past the same café every morning and the owner is seventy-two; his son works in Nagoya and will not come back. This is not about incentives. This is about whether we built a country where staying means something, and we did not.